Who should be the next head coach at West Texas A&M?

I got a text this morning asking if I really thought Don Carthel would return to WT after his name led an article about potential replacements for Coach Josh Lynn.
My answer? No.
I don't believe Coach Carthel is coming back, and I don't believe WT would offer him the job. He's in his mid-70s, living his best life in East Texas, getting to coach alongside Colby and spending time with his grandkids. I can't imagine he'd want to trade that for the demands of rebuilding a college football program.
Now, before I give you my three names, a couple of things.
First, I'm not the WT expert. That's my guys Kale Steed with Press Pass Sports and Lucas Kinsey the voice of the Buffs. They do an incredible job covering the Buffs and when it comes to finding out who will actually be the next head coach, they're the guys I'd be watching. But l will share my personal thoughts.
Second, I'm a BIG Coach Josh Lynn fan. His daughter plays club volleyball and I've always enjoyed running into him at tournaments and getting the chance to catch up. I hated seeing his time leading the Buffs come to an end, and I wish him and his family nothing but the best.
But WT has a decision to make, and if I were involved in that decision, there are three names I'd have at the top of my list.
1. JUSTIN BANE
This would be my first phone call and I'd stay on the line until he either took the job or hung up on me!
Bane is currently the offensive coordinator at Incarnate Word after an INCREDIBLE season leading the WT offense. His Buffs piled up more than 5,800 yards and 60 touchdowns last year.
And that wasn't a fluke.
Before WT, Bane was named Division II Coordinator of the Year at Central Missouri, where his offense averaged nearly 600 yards per game.
But here's why he's my No. 1 choice.
Justin Bane isn't just one of the brightest offensive minds in college football. He's one of the greatest leaders and developers of young men you'll find in this profession. We've known him since meeting him at a camp when Parker was in 7th grade and I have got to watch first hand the wisdom he pours into athletes and how they respond.
He understands WT, knows the program and has already demonstrated what he can do in Canyon.
And there's another part of this potential hire that makes it a home run.
His wife, Dr. Annie Bane, is one of the most incredible minds in sports and exercise science you will ever find. Bringing the Bane family back to Canyon could be a tremendous addition to both the football program and the university's academic community.
To me, this is the kind of hire that makes an immediate impact well beyond the football field.

2. CAID FASKE
Here's another name that makes a TON of sense.
Caid is a Bushland native, a former WT coach and one of the top rising defensive minds in college football.
He's currently the defensive coordinator at Stephen F. Austin after building some outstanding defenses at CSU Pueblo.
His defenses are known for getting after the quarterback, creating turnovers and making life miserable for opposing offenses.
During his three seasons at CSU Pueblo, his defenses forced 71 turnovers, and the program won two RMAC championships.
He's also got a National Championship on his résumé, having been part of the
Texas A&M-Commerce staff that won the 2017 NCAA Division II title.
Faske has been recognized among Dave Campbell's Texas Football's 40 Under 40 coaches, and I believe he's got a very bright future in this profession.
He's young, energetic, knows West Texas and understands what winning at the Division II level looks like.
For Caid, taking over the Buffs would be a homecoming.
And I think he'd be a really intriguing choice.

3. BEN ARBUCKLE
Here's a name that would certainly get people talking.
Ben is a Canadian native, a former WT quarterback and, at just 31 years old, has already built an impressive résumé as an offensive coordinator.
Until earlier this month, he was calling plays for the Oklahoma Sooners.
Obviously, things didn't end the way anyone hoped in Norman, but I wouldn't let that erase what Arbuckle accomplished before getting there.
His offenses at Washington State were putting up video game numbers, and his work earned him a Broyles Award nomination as one of the nation's top assistant coaches.
In 2024, Washington State averaged more than 36 points and 440 yards per game.
Ben understands the Panhandle, played at WT and knows the tradition of Buff football.
Would he be interested in returning to Canyon? I have no idea.
But if he is, I certainly think he's a name worth discussing.
Three coaches. Three different paths to the same job.
Bane brings elite offensive production, a proven connection to WT and the kind of leadership I believe can transform a program.
Faske brings defensive toughness, championship experience and deep West Texas roots.
Arbuckle brings high-level Division I experience, offensive creativity and a chance to bring a former Buff quarterback home.
If I'm making the call, Justin Bane is my guy.
But I'd feel pretty good about having all three names on the board.
Who would YOU like to see leading West Texas A&M football into its next chapter?




Comments